Contents Introduction 4 Consultation 5 Crystal Palace Draft Planning Framework 5 Core principles 6 Vision 7 National Sports Centre (NSC) 8 The Hilltop 10 Norwood Triangle Gateway 10 Additional information 12 Croydon Tramlink Extension 12 Appointment of masterplanners 12 Dialogue 13 Next steps 13 Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum 3 Introduction In October 2005, the London Development Agency (LDA) published the consultation draft of the Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework, which sets out the aspirations and vision for the future of the park. This marked the beginning of a consultation period stretching from October until 20 December 2005, which involved a two week static exhibition in a marquee at the eastern and western ends of the park, and a series of road shows at key locations, including nearby town centres. Following this extensive consultation exercise, the LDA has been further developing the ideas for the park in the context of the feedback received from the public and stakeholders, and by continuing to work with the dialogue groups. Although a number of changes to the original Draft Planning Framework are proposed (which are outlined in the following sections), in general the ideas for the park were well received and did not justify the reprinting of the full framework document. This addendum provides an overview of the proposed changes to the framework proposals largely arising out of the consultation process. It effectively draws to a close this preliminary stage of the process, allowing the recently appointed landscape-led masterplanners to produce a more detailed masterplan for the park. 4 Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum Consultation The level of interest in the consultation event was significant, with nearly 5000 visitors to the exhibition, town centre road shows and two presentations to local groups. This also included those that responded via the LDA website. Over 2,500 completed questionnaires were returned with more than 10,000 individual comments. In general, support for the proposals set out in the draft framework was strong, particularly for the overall vision and the underlying principles. Details of the consultation results can be found in the publication ‘Crystal Palace Park: Report on the LDA Public Consultation Exercise October- December 2005’ produced by Nigel Westaway & Associates which can be viewed on the crystalpalacepark.org.uk website. Crystal Palace Park Draft Planning Framework The Planning Framework was accepted as the basis for further discussion by the London Borough of Bromley (LBB) in January 2006. The document will be taken into account when assessing any planning, listed building or conservation area consent applications relating to the park. The London Borough of Bromley’s Unitary Development Plan (UDP), was formally adopted in the summer of 2006. While the Planning Framework takes account of the broad objectives of the UDP, it clearly concentrates on the particular circumstances of Crystal Palace Park. Any proposals for the park will need to accord with the development plan (comprising the London Plan and the Bromley UDP), unless material planning considerations indicate otherwise. The Draft Planning Framework document included a masterplan for the park, setting out ideas to support the vision. However, the level of detail needed for a planning application required the LDA to appoint masterplanners to work up the ideas set out in the Framework and develop new ideas resulting from their own work. This will form the basis of a planning application which is intended to be submitted to LBB in the summer of 2007. Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum 5 Core principles The Framework sets out five core principles (paragraph 4.2) which underpin the vision for the rejuvenation and regeneration of the park. The first of the five – a revived metropolitan park – makes reference in the subsequent text to “acknowledging (the park’s) historical past”, but the rich heritage embodied in the park can be reinforced by including the words ‘heritage asset’ in the first core principle. This will now read: A revived metropolitan park and heritage asset The other principles remain as: a sports and events park a sustainable park an accessible and integrated park an educational park 6 Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum Vision Although the overall vision for the park was strongly supported in the consultation process, there was no specific reference to heritage in the vision statement (paragraph 5.2). Therefore the statement has been amended and now reads as follows: Crystal Palace Park is one of the most important 19th century urban parks in the country. It contains not only significant remains from its original Joseph Paxton design but also later layers of history that reflect its changing use and status over the years. Our vision is to rejuvenate Crystal Palace Park as a metropolitan park, heritage asset, cultural, leisure, educational and recreational resource for the 21st century to meet the needs of local people, sports people and the public at large while reinterpreting and conserving its national significance. Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum 7 National Sports Centre (NSC) The Framework (Section 6.2, Area One - The NSC and Athletics Stadium) included proposals for the removal of the National Sports Centre Indoor Arena, which currently contains the swimming pool and dry side sports, to be replaced with parkland and a new sports centre closer to the station. This approach had been based on a number of factors, including: the outmoded nature of the existing building which does not meet today’s requirements for sports (see paragraph 2.5.23 of the Framework); its location within the centre of the park, detracting from the original Paxton vision and objectives for Metropolitan Open Land (MOL); the fragile nature of the mechanical plant which has been in the building for over 40 years now, and would need extensive upgrading and replacement at considerable cost; the apparent lack of any suitable alternative use which would not require large public subsidies; and the results of previous consultation showing public support to demolish the NSC. Subsequent discussions with English Heritage have led to a re-consideration of this position, exploring further options for the retention of this structure and its reuse. Following these discussions, the LDA now proposes to retain the NSC, not as a multi-use sports centre, for it doesn’t meet modern day standards and is no longer fit for purpose, but for a more low-key sports function, such as five-a-side football. 8 Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum This would require the stripping out of much of the infrastructure in the building, rafting over the swimming and diving pools and the conversion of the current squash courts along the spine of the building into changing rooms. It would also allow the removal of much of the unsightly infrastructure which has grown up around the NSC over the years and which further compromises the open nature of the park. This would need to be undertaken in phases in order to maintain sports use within the park, but would ultimately lead to a greatly improved setting for this listed building. The intention for the centre’s reuse would be to bring the park up to the edge of the building, requiring the infilling of the range of unattractive spaces which now surround the NSC, to create the appearance of a pavilion in the park. References to the total removal of the NSC within the Planning Framework should therefore be disregarded and replaced with this more conservation-based approach which retains the main indoor arena. However, these works are unlikely to be fully implemented until a new sports centre is built. For the new permanent sports centre, the intention is that, subject to a successful planning application, this would not be built until after the 2012 Olympic Games and Paralympic Games, to allow events such as the London Youth Games and the Athletics Grand Prix to continue at Crystal Palace. The LDA is committed to maintaining swimming facilities in the park, until a new permanent facility is built. This is likely to be via an upgrade to the plant servicing the existing building. Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum 9 The Hilltop The Planning Framework set out two options for the Hilltop on page 51. The first option proposed retaining and enhancing most of the Hilltop as parkland but with the provision of normal park facilities (such as play areas, toilets etc), a viewing platform and with the potential of revitalising and reusing the subway structure. The second option proposed all of the above, plus the development of a major new indoor attraction perhaps with a café/restaurant, botanical winter garden and butterfly house. The consultation results showed more support for the first option, retaining the majority of the Hilltop for parkland. Consequently, this option has been retained in the revised Masterplan Framework. Norwood Triangle Gateway The Planning Framework set out four options for the Norwood Gate (options A, B, C and D) ranging from a ‘built option’ (Option A) to a primarily ‘landscaped option’ (Option D). These are set out in Section 6 of the Framework on pages 55 and 56. The consultation results showed no clear support for any option although the landscape proposals (Options C and D) received the most support. The main issue with the built options principally related to the residential component which raised a number of concerns from local groups. Following this feedback, the LDA commissioned three architectural firms to re-consider the Norwood Triangle Gate, largely along the lines of Option C with an absence of any residential element. The brief for the architects was drawn up in consultation with the dialogue group, clearly setting out the elements people wanted to see within this gate. As expected, the three designs, which all included a performance space, café and better connections to the park, showed some similarities in the way these elements were arranged, but all proposed ‘gates’ which were remarkably different in character. The schemes were presented to the main dialogue group with two receiving clear support. The Arup Associates proposal, which was one of these, has been incorporated into the revised Masterplan Framework along with the retention of the National Sports Centre Indoor Arena as explained in more detail on pages 8 and 9. 10 Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum Revised masterplan Additional information Since producing the Planning Framework and adopting the changes set out in this addendum, TfL have progressed with their proposals for the Croydon Tramlink Extension and the masterplanners for the park have been appointed. The dialogue process is continuing, helping the masterplanners to develop their ideas in the context of the revised masterplan framework. Also, following the production of this broad vision, the first changes to improve the park are about to happen. Croydon Tramlink Extension A proposal to bring the Croydon Tramlink Extension to Crystal Palace by Transport for London (TfL), which was mentioned in the Planning Framework (paragraph 4.2.27), has now been the subject of a consultation exercise. The proposals show the tram route linking Croydon and Upper Norwood town centre via Crystal Palace Station. The intention is to bring the tram close to the Norwood Triangle Gate where it can interchange with the bus station. TfL are considering a number of route options for the tram, either running up Anerley Hill or through the park. A decision will not be taken by TfL on their preferred route until summer 2007. The planning application for the park will reflect the preferred route. Appointment of masterplanners In May 2006, the LDA advertised for firms to undertake the masterplanning of the park. This was a major step forward, marking the next stage of the rejuvenation of Crystal Palace Park. At the end of July, and following a significant number of submissions, a winning team was selected to take forward this important work. Latz + Partner, together with a large multidisciplinary consultant team, were appointed and are now taking forward this work. The intention is to use the masterplan as the basis for the main planning application for the park to be submitted to the London Borough of Bromley in autumn 2007. 12 Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum Dialogue The park users and sports users working groups, together with the main dialogue group, are continuing to discuss and input into the development of ideas for the park. These groups and the wider stakeholders will work with the masterplanners to develop a masterplan which sets out the future direction for the park. As part of this process, the masterplanner’s consultation consultants will be developing a broader community engagement strategy. Next steps The masterplanning team will be developing their ideas for the park in the context of the Planning Framework and also in consultation with the public and key stakeholders. There will be a further exhibition of these ideas before the application is submitted to the London Borough of Bromley in the autumn of 2007. In the meantime, and subject to the appropriate approvals, works to improve access to the park including the removal of unsightly and unnecessary fencing and turnstiles will start in spring 2007. Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum 13 14 Crystal Palace Park Planning Framework Addendum Other languages and formats This document is also available in large print, braille, on disk, audio cassette and in the languages listed below. For a copy, please contact the LDA Communications Team: London Development Agency, Palestra, 197 Blackfriars Road London SE1 8AA Tel: 020 7593 9000 Email: communications@lda.gov.uk Textphone: 020 7593 9001 Photographs: Robin Buckle, Johanna Gibbons, Tobias Kramer Rendered images and drawings: Arup Associates This document has been compiled by Robin Buckle. The LDA would like to thank everyone who has contributed to the production of the revised masterplan. Designed by Brent Design Unit: design@brent.gov.uk Arabic Hindi Bengali Punjabi Chinese Turkish Greek Urdu Gujarati Vietnamese London Development Agency, Palestra, 197 Blackfriars Road London SE1 8AA Tel: 020 7593 8000 Fax: 020 7593 8002 Textphone: 020 7593 8001 www.lda.gov.uk 02.07 BDU 5395